“
★★★★★
Great company and they are family owned,please use this company.money well spent.no issues
Price assessment
Reasonable price
Services
Gutter repairs, Roof repair for storm & wind damage, Roof inspection
“
★★★★★
Once I agreed to move forward, the scheduling process was seamless. The crew arrived exactly when they said they would, at 8:00 a.m. sharp, and began setting up with almost military precision. Tarps were laid down to protect my shrubs and patio furniture, ladders were positioned safely, and within minutes the sound of steady, organized work filled the air. I appreciated that the foreman took the time to introduce himself and confirm all the details before they began — no surprises, no last-minute changes.
Throughout the day, I watched how efficiently the crew worked. Every member knew their role; they communicated constantly and never once appeared disorganized or careless. What impressed me most was how clean they kept the job site. I’ve heard horror stories from friends who found nails and debris for weeks after their roof was replaced, but Five Star Roofing left my property spotless. By the end of the day, it was hard to believe a full tear-off and replacement had just taken place.
The quality of their work spoke for itself. The new shingles looked flawless — perfectly aligned, evenly nailed, and finished with precision around the vents and chimney. Even from the street, the difference was obvious. My neighbors commented on how professional it looked and how quickly the entire project was completed. Five Star didn’t just replace my roof; they elevated the entire curb appeal of my home.
What also stood out was the pride they took in their craftsmanship. Before leaving, the foreman did a full walk-around with me, checking every section of the roof and making sure I was completely satisfied. He answered every question I had, pointed out the new flashing they installed for better leak protection, and gave me clear instructions on maintenance. You could tell he genuinely cared that the work reflected the company’s reputation.
In the weeks following the installation, we had a couple of heavy rainstorms — the kind that used to make me nervous. But this time, there wasn’t a single drip, draft, or issue. Everything held up perfectly. That peace of mind alone made the investment worth every penny. Knowing I could trust their work during unpredictable Long Island weather was incredibly reassuring.
The office team followed up afterward as well, which I didn’t expect but really appreciated. They called to make sure everything was holding up and asked if I had any lingering questions. That kind of aftercare is rare in the contracting world and showed me that Five Star Roofing truly stands behind its name. Their customer service didn’t end when the crew packed up — it continued well after the last shingle was nailed down.
From start to finish, every interaction I had with Five Star Roofing Co. was marked by professionalism, efficiency, and integrity. They delivered exactly what they promised: a strong, beautiful roof completed on time and at a fair price. It’s refreshing to see a company that still believes in doing things the right way, without cutting corners or upselling unnecessary work.
If I could give more than five stars, I would. Five Star Roofing Co. transformed what could have been a stressful home repair into a smooth, confidence-building experience. I’ve already recommended them to my neighbors and family members in the area, and I wouldn’t hesitate to do so again. Westbury is lucky to have a roofing company of this caliber — honest, reliable, and genuinely dedicated to their craft.
Price assessment
Great price
Price
$1–2,000
Services
Gutter repairs
“
★★★★★
I had water coming down in almost every room of my house. A team responded in about 40 minutes, tarped the roof and the road to recovery began.
Nick is honest, calming, displaying excellent communication skills rarely found today. I would recommend Five Star Roofing to anyone.
Price assessment
Reasonable price
Price
$20,000+
Services
Roof repair for storm & wind damage, Roof inspection, Roof repair, Roof installation, Roof damage repair, Service not listed
“
★★★★★
Nick is awesome, as said by others. He is friendly, professional, honest, fair & knowledgeable. He inspected the roof for an estimate, showed me the problems and explained the alternatives. He used a cool drone to show the roof and it's problems. Lupai in the office was also helpful. We received a detailed written estimate. Next we set a time for the job.
Flat roof was done over from scratch and slate roofing replaced by shingles roofing that looked like slate. High quality materials were used for both jobs. It looks great. Nick found some aged damage, he had it re-enforced for durability. The two crews were great, they knew what exactly to do, to perfection. They did a neat beautiful job and cleaned up immaculately. Great crew directed by Nick, great job.
Services
Roof inspection
“
★★★★★
What a great experience with this company. Nick was fantastic and made my 96 year old uncle feel comfortable with working with him. We had 3 bids and Nicks was right on point. Renaldo did the work today and it is fantastic!! Also his invoice is so detailed oriented. Made us feel good. Will use again if need be.
“
★★★★☆
From the initial consultation to the final inspection, Five Star Roofing Co. demonstrated expertise and commitment to excellence. Their team conducted a thorough assessment and delivered a detailed estimate, ensuring transparency at every step. Nick was particularly knowledgeable, addressing concerns with clarity and offering insightful recommendations tailored to the building’s needs. The workmanship reflects superior craftsmanship, and the project was executed with precision. Their dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is evident, making them a top choice for anyone seeking reliable roofing solutions in New York
Price assessment
Reasonable price
